On that list, I've had the V3, DMS, & Tac30. The V3 is the best quality scope, but might not be suitable for the matches you shoot (distance, no illumination, etc.). The DMS just felt cheap, glass was mediocre, QC is hit/miss. The Tac30 had a huge reticle that I did not care for, but others do. The bdc feature did work. I hated the push button control for the illumination. The MTAC appears a better option. I'd suggest the Strike Eagle because of the price you're getting. You'll sell it eventually, & move up to a better scope, resale will be better on it. It's still in demand, & will sell quickly here.