Jump to content
Brian Enos's Forums... Maku mozo!

Which powder do you prefer for 38 super Comp


magpulled

Recommended Posts

  • Replies 87
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

the primers look good, no sign of over pressure, I have a Caspian, the load shoots pretty good, the sight doesn't move to much, 

as I stated, I'm new to open guns, just going on advice from whom I bought the gun from, seems to work. I have been shooting a 40 in limited for years so I am not new to the process

I will be talking with others locally who have more experience and I will try more powders in the future.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

3n38 and n105 are the powders from VV to shoot on open major.

 

340 is WAY TO FAST

3n37 and n350 makes some hefty pressures as well

 

 

n105 = supersafe all day

3n38 = safe in right ammounts. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

It maybe to fast, on the burn chart, 340, 3n37, 3n38 and 105 are all right together. I know from the chart that 340 is faster than the others because it's at the top of them, but how much faster? I will experiment with other powders that are slower and produce more gas, this is a starting point.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

On 7/31/2017 at 6:42 AM, jnkill said:

new to open, but all the guys here running 38 say 105, 10.5 gr 125 gr montana gold

Super Comp has less case capacity than a 38 Super. That being said, your charge for SC case should be lower than that of a Super case. I load 10.5 of N105 at 1.235 with a 115 MG JHP and make 170 PF in a Trubor. And that charge of N105 is about 1/8th of an inch from spilling from the Super case. I do know people that load N105 in an SC case, but almost all are running a 115 JHP.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

 

Load data in the 38 Super for N340 is interesting.

 

Vihtavuori data 124 Hornady FMJ-FP @ 1.260" OAL, 5.5" barrel:

N330 Max 6.4 gr, 1340 fps

N340 Max 6.6 gr, 1281 fps

3N37 Max 7.4 gr,  1271 fps

N350 Max 6.9 gr, 1275 fps

N105 Max 10.4 gr, 1501 fps

 

Sierra Manual (5th Edition, 4th printing), 125 grain and 130 grain bullets (various OALs), 5" barrel:

N340 Max 6.8 gr, 1300 fps

3N37 Max 7.8 gr, 1300 fps

3N38 Max 8.7 gr, 1300 fps

N105 Max 10.0 gr, 1350 fps (1350 is the highest speed they record for their data in these bullet weights)

 

Compared to (Sierra 125/130 data also):

Titegroup Max 6.0 gr, 1300 fps

Power Pistol Max 7.8 gr, 1350 fps

Silhouette Max 7.3 gr, 1250 fps

HS-6 Max 7.9 gr, 1250 fps

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I load 7 gr of VV340, 125 gr HAP, 1.225 oal, Starline SC case, and CCI spp, my pf is 167. There is more room in the case for more powder. The primers are in very good condition, can push this load some more. All of the reading I have done since making the jump to open, is to reduce muzzle movement and keep the dot on the target. I don't know if this is the right combination or not, and understand I will try other combinations, but am not disappointed with the recommendation of this load. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

On 8/2/2017 at 6:11 PM, GrumpyOne said:

Super Comp has less case capacity than a 38 Super. That being said, your charge for SC case should be lower than that of a Super case. I load 10.5 of N105 at 1.235 with a 115 MG JHP and make 170 PF in a Trubor. And that charge of N105 is about 1/8th of an inch from spilling from the Super case. I do know people that load N105 in an SC case, but almost all are running a 115 JHP.

I'm shooting super, not sc. 10.5 of n105 at 1.230 with 125 blue bullet and make 168pf

Link to comment
Share on other sites

On 8/2/2017 at 6:11 PM, GrumpyOne said:

Super Comp has less case capacity than a 38 Super. That being said, your charge for SC case should be lower than that of a Super case. I load 10.5 of N105 at 1.235 with a 115 MG JHP and make 170 PF in a Trubor. And that charge of N105 is about 1/8th of an inch from spilling from the Super case. I do know people that load N105 in an SC case, but almost all are running a 115 JHP.

 

Why is SC's case volume smaller?

 

I thought the only difference between Super and SC was that the rim was cut down a bit on SuperComp brass?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

When I tried 105, 10 grains was level with the case mouth.

 I pretty much tried them all, and think 350 is the best choice for MY pistol, which is a "shorty" with 3 holes in the bbl, behind the comp.

With the same pistol, if I put in my 9mm bbl, with no holes, Autocomp is my first choice, followed by 350.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 hour ago, RaylanGivens said:

 

Why is SC's case volume smaller?

 

I thought the only difference between Super and SC was that the rim was cut down a bit on SuperComp brass?

 

Starline's 38 Supercomp case walls near the head might be a little thicker than many companies' 38 Super brass.  This would reduce volume. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 4 weeks later...
On 8/2/2017 at 8:37 PM, superdude said:

 

Load data in the 38 Super for N340 is interesting.

 

Vihtavuori data 124 Hornady FMJ-FP @ 1.260" OAL, 5.5" barrel:

N330 Max 6.4 gr, 1340 fps

N340 Max 6.6 gr, 1281 fps

3N37 Max 7.4 gr,  1271 fps

N350 Max 6.9 gr, 1275 fps

N105 Max 10.4 gr, 1501 fps

 

Sierra Manual (5th Edition, 4th printing), 125 grain and 130 grain bullets (various OALs), 5" barrel:

N340 Max 6.8 gr, 1300 fps

3N37 Max 7.8 gr, 1300 fps

3N38 Max 8.7 gr, 1300 fps

N105 Max 10.0 gr, 1350 fps (1350 is the highest speed they record for their data in these bullet weights)

 

Compared to (Sierra 125/130 data also):

Titegroup Max 6.0 gr, 1300 fps

Power Pistol Max 7.8 gr, 1350 fps

Silhouette Max 7.3 gr, 1250 fps

HS-6 Max 7.9 gr, 1250 fps

 

you need 1450 fps for a 115 gr bullet to barely make major and 1350 for a 125 gr, the manuals have to take into account maximum listed pressures, but that is also meant for every gun , not the open guns we run

Link to comment
Share on other sites

On 8/1/2017 at 2:25 PM, ano said:

VV340 in open? Im sorry but that person is plain dumb. 

VV340 is slower than HS6/ WW540 that is an accepted burn rate for open (9 Major in particular)

VV340 burn rate is is equal to Silhouette / WAP, SR4756 that are an accepted burn rate for open also.

 

Yes 3N37, 3N38 and N105 are better but if I was ever inclined to do 9 Major N340 would be my power of choice, but I am happy staying with .38SC

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I like 3N38, but it can be difficult to get ahold of sometimes. I've used AA#7 for years in my 45s and worked up loads for my 38. Made it feel a lot more like my 45s with less recoil. I think I'll just stick to it for a while.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now



×
×
  • Create New...