This totally depends on what you want. There are tons of mag buttons out there. Some are paddle style some are buttons and they are all different sizes and textures. Some people have trouble with the paddle style buttons, myself included. I will occasionally bump the button with my palm when I'm really pushing it. I personally love the feel and size of the STI paddle button. That said I'm very close to getting rid of it because of mag drop issues. I need it but if I drop one more mag I'm going to learn to do without. If you can make that button work with your hands then I would highly recommend it.