For the most part I think it will depend on your budget and no 38 super and 9 major are not the same. From a true performance standpoint 38 super comp is likely the best. 9 major is becoming popular, because people were once able to get cheap brass, I'm not sure if that is correct anymore.
My Bedell shorty in 38 SC runs flawlessly and I have SV building another 38 SC Open gun for me. Brazos makes some fine guns and there are many other good smiths out there.
Good luck in your choice, just get a gun from a reputable smith that will stand behind his product.