Jump to content
Brian Enos's Forums... Maku mozo!

Replacement for 3N38


kdj

Recommended Posts

I've always used VV N350 in my 38 super. In fact, I've never owned a powder that wasn't VV. I'd been about to try 3N38 in my new shortie gun and now I hear that due to a "misclassification" VV powders can only be shipped as explosives. Until this is fixed that effectively means no shipping of VV.

So what should I try now? I've read the various threads concerning 7625, 4756, AA7 and now TrueBlue and am confused.

All I want is a nice clean consistant powder that make 169 PF comfortably in a 38 super case, has lots of gas pressure and is both soft and flat ... and I can get delivered on a regular basis!

Not too much to ask, right :P

I'm tending to 4756 or TrueBlue. Anyone want to speak up and steer me in the right direction since I don't like having to play with loads?

Thanks,

Kevin

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Kevin-

I have recently tried 1 pound of True Blue in a 9major gun due to the unavailability of SP2 and 3n38. I really liked its performance in my gun. My gun has a 4.5" barrel / 3 snort holes / and a 5 port EGW comp. It didn't seem to have the same blast as 3n38, but the dot movement seemed the same to me. The accuracy wasn't as good as 3n38, but was close enough for USPSA. IMO...

Also....thanks to Caspian9major for the good TB load data....

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I tried 4756 last week. I only have 115 gr. bullets. I could make major with this powder/bullet combo, but I had to fill up the case all the way to the top, and then cram the bullet down on top of it. Shot side by side with my regular load of N350, I liked the feel of the Vhit load better.

I'm going to try and make it out to the range today with some Win540 (same as HS6) and some HS7. Again using 115 gr. bullets.

I'll try and post my findings later.

I'm toying with the idea of working up a new load. Vhit is sometimes hard to find locally. I usually try and stock up from the vendors at the big matches. But it might be nice to have a back-up load already worked up in case the supplies of Vhit dry up.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I recived a letter from Kaltron (vihtavuori) importers the other day, stateing that there will be no shipments until the classification of the powder has been changed. Unless they are sent by placarded truck. Which belive me is VERY expensive. Kaltron are in the process of doing this so it should not be too long.

Be aware that anyone shipping powder to you by fedex ground is in brach of DOT regulations untill this powder has been reclassfied.

Saying that we do have supplies of VV powder on hand and are awaiting another shippment immeninent any time, we are located in Phoenix and personal collection can be arranged.

"Sorry Brian for making thi sound like and adverisment, but I think it is neccessary for people to know the truth and still be able to get powder if they need it, I will understand if you delete this message"

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Just got back from the range. My little thermometer read a balmy 105 degrees in the shade.

I loaded a 115 gr. Zero JHP over Win 540. Charge weights from 8.0 to 10.0. It felt really good, and shot very flat. I'm going to have to play with this some more.

I also loaded some HS-7. Charge weights from 8.5 to 10.5. I barely made major with the top load, but the primers were still rounded with no signs of flowing back into the firing pin hole. This is a relatively dense powder. There is still a lot of room for more powder in the case. This load also shot very flat, and felt a little better than my N350 load with the same bullet. It burned dirty, though. It was throwing unburned granules out of the gun when the empty case would eject. This was somewhat distracting. This might go away with some higher pressure loads. I might try loading this up a little hotter and see how it does.

If I get a chance, I'll load up 100 of the Win 540 loads and do some more direct comparison with my N350 load. Probably wouldn't hurt to shoot for accuracy as well.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

IIRC, the biggest problem with 540 was that it was very rough on comps. It would errode the baffles something fierce.

Hmmm. I had only heard that about AA#7. Didn't know 540 did that too.

What about HS-7? Any issues? Does it stop spitting unburned grains out when you get it loaded to a high enough pressure?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Winchester action pistol is no longer in production but Ramshot silhouette is the same powder, might give it a shot...seems like it makes major OK. 4756 seems to be an OK powder if you buy 5 pound cans of it...i use it in my 9mm production gun and it shoots good and soft(even without a comp) my load was 6.3 grains of 4756 and a 115 FMJ..i recently got a can of powder that was a little slow..my gun would stovepipe with 6.3, i had to bump it up to 6.7 and thats damn near a case full on the 9mm. i am going to burn up the rest of it, then im switchin to something more uniform..probably U clays or something similar.

Last time i checked Clark Custom guns had SP2 powder. 8 pounds for 120 dollars..

i was curious as to why i couldnt get any VV powders, i guess now i know.

Does blue dot work in an OPEN gun?? just a thought

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I like 4756 in my open blaster. I used to use 3N38 until the local supply ran dry last year so I went looking for a replacement. I can't tell the difference between the 3N38 and 4756 under a 124 in my 5" S2 comped pistol but my wallet sure can! It's not quite as clean as the VV but I can still shoot 1500 rounds between cleaning with no fear of malfunction and that's all that matters.

I tried 7625 in my gun and while a lot of shooters use and like it I found it didn't do as good a job in keeping the muzzle down - ineffective in my gun I suppose.

I haven't run into the massive charge/power factor swings others have experienced but then I only bought 1.5 lbs to try it out and then went to 5lb cans once I settled on the 4756. Both lots were exactly the same for thrown weight and power factor.

I currently run 8.4 grs 4756 under a 124 in standard super at 1.275 MAX OAL. This gives me a 174pf and perfectly balances my pistol. 8.5 chronoed 181 but it sure felt soft!

I tried the 115 with 4756 and it just seems too wierd to be loading with such a compressed charge. It looks like you dip the case, strike off the extra, and stand on the loader to stuff that bullet in. No matter though since I like 124 better anyway.

YMMV

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 1 month later...

I finally have my new gun in hand and I tried a couple of powder experiments this weekend.

Since I had no idea of where the gun would factor out, I was conservative and not all of the loads were major.

My observations, using a 121g in Supercomp brass:

7.5g of N350 (roughly my old load) factored to 161 and was pretty harsh in recoil

7.8g of TrueBlue factored to around the same. It was slightly less harsh than 350 with a little less dot bounce. It only half filled the case, which is an advantage. It was *noticably* dirtier to shoot than the other powders I tried.

?? of W540 factored to about 155. Slightly less snappy than the Vit and a little more dot movement. I didn't shoot much of this.

And since I'd managed to lay hands on some -

10g of 3N38, factored to 167. Softer in recoil and very manageable dot bounce. Very loud and a sheet of flame is apparently visible from the comp and porpoise

holes but I didn't notice it. Very clean.

So, my conclusion is that it's worth the effort to find 3N38 and it's my powder of choice for the moment. I'll try a load of about 10.1 in my gun and I'll try to avoid competing with Ong45 for the "most spectators' teeth rattled" award :lol:

Kevin

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I have used AA7, VV3N37, VV3N38, IMR7525, IMR 4756 and most recently HS7, all with 115 and 125 bullets. Due to price, availability and so on, I just settled on HS7 and 125 grain bullets. FWIW, the HS7 load at 172-175 PF is the most reliable, shoots flat (but it hits in the hand) is fairly clean, and I can find it anywhere.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Guest Larry Cazes

Kevin, I have had pretty good results loading HS6 with both 125gr. and 115 gr. MG JHPs and at $118 locally for 8lbs and $98.00 from powder valley it is easy to get and relatively cheap. The 125s loaded to 170 pf are a nice accurate low recoil load with moderate dot movement but our new blaster really shines with 115 grain MG JHPs loaded to 170 pf with 8.9 grains of HS6. The 115 load is a bit dirtier and hits your hand a little harder but very flat. How has the new shorty worked out so far? I am anxious to hear about the characteristics of the custom comp.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...