Change 7 shot to 6?

[twister]

Is it possible to change a 7 shot L frame to a 6 shot? Thanks for any help,Dave.

[Toolguy]

The short answer is yes. If you're lucky and the cylinder fits the frame and barrel all you have to do is change the cylinder and hand. If not lucky ( about a 50 - 50 chance) then you have to fit the cylinder.

[Hi-Power Jack]

why?

[twister]

Because I'd like a 5" l frame to compete with. The only way I can get one is to build it myself.

[granderojo]

I was able to make it work w/out any fitting problems. I started with a 7 shot (686+) and found a nice 6 shot cylinder for a good price and it works. Timing and clearances are all good. I needed a 6 shot gun for one of the games.

Edited December 15, 2012 by granderojo

[NOSAJ19]

I have a S&W 686 5" 7 shot. It was a great shooter as a 7 shot. I had the cylinder replaced with a 6 shot cylinder & it was terrible. It required an experienced gunsmith to get it just right. It's now fantastic & a keeper. I'm considering fitting a 4" barrel.

Cheers, Ando.

[Toolguy]

I'm sure you'll like the 4" a lot better. You can send me that junky old 5" barrel.

[toothguy]

I'm sure you'll like the 4" a lot better. You can send me that junky old 5" barrel.

And I will be gracious enough to accept the discarded 7 shot cylinder.

[westczek]

It is very doable. I swaped a 6 shot cyliner from one gun into my 686 plus, worked without issue. I even fitted a new from the factory 6 shot cyliner. A small but sharp file and some patience is all that is needed.

Westczek

[Jim Watson]

My six shot cylinder dropped right into my seven shot gun, timing, gap, and all.

So I ordered a loose cylinder off the www. IT didn't fit.

So I coughed up the money to have S&W furnish and fit one.

I have way more in the gun than I will ever get out of it, but it is a good shooter.