Jump to content
Brian Enos's Forums... Maku mozo!

M&P9 vs. the Pro: range test #1


mike cyrwus

Recommended Posts

Did some chrono testing last Friday.

Accuracy was more than acceptable with all loads; my M&P9 has a great trigger on it and the M&P9 Pro only got a quick polish; so I cannot comment about accuracy; yet.

The synopsis: The Pro has about 15-40fps higher velocities; the felt recoil was noticably less with the Pro; no loads were snappy with the pro and the sight fell on paper faster.

Also, for a seat of the pants comparison for defense ammo recoil, I put about 5 rounds of Federal 147gr HST through each of them. The 4.25" barrel was much flippier than the Pro.

Once I do a full trigger on the Pro; Ill bench them and shoot groups.

-enjoy.

LOAD #1:

125gr JSP (old .355" star bullets) 4.1gr titegroup 1.13" OAL WSP

4.25" barrel 5" barrel

SD 18.15 17.04

AVG 1056.8 1072.4

avg PF 132.1 134.05

LOAD #2:

speer 124gr fmj 4.1gr titegroup 1.13 oal WSP

4.25" 5"

SD 8.90 15.57

AVG 1074 1090.56

avg PF 133.17 135.29

LOAD #3:

115gr fmj 4.5g titegroup 1.13"oal WSP

4.25" 5"

SD 15.67 11.92

AVG 1157.9 1189.1

avg PF 133.16 136.75

LOAD #4:

115gr factory 9mm Speer

Blazer Brass

4.25" 5"

SD 15.75 9.69

AVG 1100 1142.73

avg PF 126.5 131.4

Link to comment
Share on other sites

When I chrono'd w/ my 9L, I shot 147 jacketed, 1.160 OAL, 3.5-3.6grs TG through the 9L, MP9, and MP9 w/ Storm Lake barrel.

The 9L was in the 935-940 fps range.

The MP9 was in the 885-890 fps range.

The MP9 w/ Storm Lake barrel was in the 910-919 fps range.

The 9L had a good 45 fps difference and the accuracy was better. The little extra barrel and sight radius makes a difference.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I'd be very interested to hear your subjective evaluation of the differences.

More stuff like your description of the difference in feel of recoil.

Is it easier to shoot more accurately on the course, regardless of any difference in inherent accuracy?

Does it handle noticeably differently?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Mike - FWIW, SAAMI max OAL for 9x19 is 1.169". It's shorter (1.13"?) for .40 S&W due to the wider bullets; I guess they tend to drag on the mag when loaded longer.

I know, but length is length, and if Im not smokin crack, the 9mm and 40 mag bodies are the same.

I better go check so I dont look like an idiot.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Mike, you wouldnt look like that no matter what your answers/observation was, everyone overlooks stuff and this is an informational forum, so learning is trick here.

Ive loaded my rounds to 1.160 since Feb and they have been flawless. I got that length from my buddy Jeff D. I ve also loaded my rounds to 1.180 w/ 100% function, Daniel Cook loads his to 1.185 w/ great reliability. When I measured the inside of my mags, I think I came up w/ something like 1.190 or 1.195, but it has been a while since I measured them.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Dang it dan, was wondering where you saw the 9L? I think I would rather try the 9L and tune it to my liking.

At a gun show in Lakeland, Florida. One of the really big distributors had it on the table at $699.00. A little too high for me, but you might try Bud's Gun Shop.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Shoot Straight in the Orlando area has/had the pro. believe it or not but I got mine friday for 579.00, I don't think they know what they have. I am sure they will have them this weekend at the gun show.

Edited by ormondopen
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...