Shawn,
It doesn't matter. There is no "gaining advantage" in equipment rules. If DNROI wants to clarify it to be empty mags are ok in pockets in front of the hip bone, by all means, ask. Everything in 5.2.4, Appendix E3, D4, etc. ALL say equipment, "spare magazines", etc. It does not say "ammunition". Sorry, but you run the risk of slippery slope by allowing a reading in of this advantage hoohaw you keep talking about. It does not matter, the equipment is in the wrong place after the buzzer...
I will gladly accept and applaud a change for this, but I don't agree with you that just because the mag is empty means it's not part of the equipment - by the reading of the rules.
You can warn everyone you want. I keep telling them to stop loading 11 in their charge mag, but every once in a while someone gets banged into open on an unloaded start.
I'll play Devil's advocate here for a moment -- granted we don't often see this situation.....
Competitor has a gun with a mag safety. Competitor also has an extra mag, differently colored than the ones on his belt, that he carries empty in his front pocket, for the specific purpose of inserting it into the gun to drop the hammer with a trigger pull at the end of the COF. Is that allowed? Is it allowed if it's a tube and basepad -- no follower and spring?
No because that is equipment forward of the hipbone.