If you put it in historical perspective it makes sense. Most of the guns mentioned were probably made in the 50s and 60s and into the 70s. There was no .40 or 10mm at the time, 38 Super had a poor accuracy reputation because they headspaced on the semi-rim and 9mm was still pretty uncommon in this country. So, if you wanted to shoot an auto in bullseye you shot 1911 .45, got a Model 52 and shot .38Spl or had a 1911 modified to shoot .38Spl. That was pretty much it as far as choices went. R,
Actually, it was to have guns with the same feel. High Standard .22's were very popular. The Military grip version had the grip angle the same as a 1911. A centerfire pistol, that was smaller than .45 could have a lighter trigger than a .45, and would have less recoil. Then a .45 would finish the guns needed for a 2700 match.
A model 52 grip angle is much different than a 1911, why not have one that matches it? This is also the reason for Kart and Day .22 conversions.
Dan,
I'm not discounting that it was to have guns that felt the same, but my point was that there weren't any alternatives at the time. You shot a revolver, a 1911 or a M52 for centerfire...that was about it. So sure, if you wanted your rimfire and centerfire to feel the same and you wanted to shoot something milder a .38Spl modification to a 1911 made sense. Nobody would bother doing that now with all the available options out there. R,
I checked with my brother, he is the source of the Clark guns and the retired bullseye shooter, and he added one other dimension to the reason for .38 SPL, there is no easier bullet to score than a full wadcutter. There is no doubt if you touch or cut a scoring ring with a full wadcutter. The picture of the Giles gun and target show the perfectly cut holes.
Bullseye is also a one hand game so light recoil and quick sight recovery is very important. The long slide and the heavy full length BoMar rib added weight and more control as well as sight radius.
Barrels are mentioned in a couple of posts and the .38 long slide is interesting in that Jim Clark manufactured the barrel by sleeving a .45 NM chamber and attaching that to a 38 caliber barrel. There were no 6” barrels or slides available in those days so they handmade them. The slide is handmade with the extra inch cut from another slide and welded on. The ramp is modified and a small filler piece is welded to the frame to help the flat nose rounds feed. A heavy rounded crimp also helps the rounds feed better.
The one thing that was available in that period was a seemingly endless supply of cheap surplus GI issue parts. Taking a hacksaw to a slide today would make many people a little nervous.