Pig breaks work. Look at the sjc titan. Gigantic but works. Look at any if the mid barrel breaks for dissident arms.
I dont mind hanging a 15 lb slab of metal off my barrel if it means not feeling any recoil.
That being said, for being more lightweight, the taccom solution did an ok job of breaking the recoil.
Normally for comps that are both lightweight and small in size you would not expect it to break the recoil as much as it did