There are a lot of broken charging handles in this thread. The issue I have is the reports are very SHORT on details. What was it made of, who made it and where did it break are very important questions. To simply state that a Brand X steel charging handle is stronger than any aluminum variant is disingenuous.
I would dare say that a charging handle properly machined from a 7075-T6 forging is indestructable. A Colt charging handle would be a good example. I would have to guess that any bent or broken charging handles were made from 6061 aluminum which is a very poor choice for ANY piece that is part of the operating system on an AR-15. I am willing to go out on a limb and say that a 7075-T6 charging handle can't be bent or broken. At 74-78K psi tensile strength and 63-69K psi yield strength, you would have to be SERIOUSLY abusing your rifle to break or bend it.
A charging handle made from 1144 stress proof (DSA) is undoubtedly a strong piece but I'm not quite sure it is better. DPMS does not state what type of steel their charging handle is made from. I have to believe it is a price point part as 7075-T6 is around twice the cost of any steel that a charging handle could be made from.