Well I did another batch of 45's, they came out great. Here is my assessment.
When I did the batch that came out with a dull satin mat type finish was a combination of problems. I normally do larger batches 200-250 shells.However this was a small batch of 75. Not thinking I still used 5 pounds of SS media and the 1/2 Tsp of lemi shine, plus 2 Tsp of Dawn and a smaller amount of water and tumbled it 3 hours.
My belief is that 5 Lbs. of SS media and to much lemi shine, tumbled for to long on such a small batch of brass cause the problem. It's like all the ss media, "Beat the heck" out of the brass for 3 hours.