I just received a brand new Rival-S via warranty replacement for failure to feed which may very well have been this same issue.
I cannot reproduce the issue on the new Rival-S, so it appears they have fixed the issue.
Here's a side by side with another Rival-S on the left.
The channel running across the plunger is definitely wider on the new Rival-S on the right. I cannot find any other discernable differences.