I guess I'm just having a hard time deciding. I don't have the ability to check them each out.
On paper, it seems that the Banner is the best for my needs. 1x-4x, I like the Circle X reticle, and it has a 78.5' FOV at 1x and 25' at 4x
Bushnell makes good optics.
Next it would seem the Trophy is nice - Circle x reticle, 73' FOV at 1.75x, 30' at 4x, with a 4.1" eye relief.
The Simmons . . . well, it has a 76' FOV at 1x, which is good. And a 23.5' FOV at 5x, which is pretty nice considering it is 5x instead of 4x.
Does the Simmons really have better clarity, contrast, light gathering, etc. vs. the Bushnell?