I've also got that issue.. Red dots and Eotech's give me the dreaded 'starburst'. I've tried all kinds and came to the same conclusion about an etched reticle. On the advice of a fellow shooter at my club, I tried Swamp Fox's Blade. (https://www.swampfoxoptics.com/blade-1x25-prism). its meant for an AR, but works like a charm on my PCC (AR9 form factor). The Blade has the 'Circle of death' like the Eotech which great on the steel challenge. It also has bullet drop marks that make shooting USPSA like cheating. You can usually find them on sale or discount codes are easily found. I love mine...Hope that helps!