This is an excerpt from a post I put on the IDPA forum.
*****
The crux of the whole problem is Berryville’s refusal to understand the protocol or etiquette required for a rulebook of this caliber. Without being to critical, an international organization needs to have WORLD CLASS definitions and use appropriate language that would hold up in a court of law. We all understand the “intent” or “spirit” of what they want this sport to be, and perhaps that would be fine if it were just for 100 people to go shoot a local match. But on a national scale, it would have done everyone concerned justice to have a professionally written rulebook that would make a lawyer blush (sorry folks, that’s the world we live in).
There are a lot of improvements in the format and clarifications of many rules and debates from the previous LGB. However, many seem to think that just because a document is well written that it’s a good job. I would argue that a well written document in good format is the bare minimum requirement of a rule book. To say that because something has improved tremendously is warrant enough for its acceptance is like saying that a product with a major safety recall that is resolved is now an excellent product. No, it’s now on par with what it should have been in the first place. I applaud the efforts of the powers that be for the corrections and improvements, but I’m not getting excited about it.
The true issue that anyone with an analytical eye should have seen is that the content of the book is still lacking. It’s still chocked full of opinion, self proclaimed definitions and jargon. It’s not so much a rulebook as it is someone’s definition of what they want in a game while all the time discrediting those who would play it as a game!
Incredible irony!
I’m not discrediting the fact that writing a rulebook and managing a national club is difficult. Being a parent is difficult, but that doesn’t mean I can use that as an excuse to be a poor parent. Neither can HQ use it as an excuse to put out a product for it’s customers that is still mediocre at best.
I’ve said my peace. I can either play by the rules or take my marbles and go home. Or I can start my own game… hmmm…
Joe
IDPA# A18887
Edited: Removed statement from original quote so that the entire message would be within the forum guidelines.