You know, I really do try to stay out of these bizarre arguments.
If the shooter is out of cover, PE. That's an obvious call.
Blow past a target? PE. COF failure, right?
Shoot extra rounds/not enough rounds in a Limited Vickers stage? PE. Deal with it.
What's a Tribal Rule that comes into play here? You're either IN cover or you're not.
Local Tribal Rules allowing shooters to attend matches more than once without paying the IDPA membership? Not a big deal for most of the civilized world.
A Tribal Rule that let's 40S&W shoot in CDP is obviously a violation or a local outlaw match.
The reason people think they're getting "Tribal Rules" on calls, especially cover PE's is because of the way it's called at a person's local range. If it's called "tight", then there's usually no problem at a higher tier match.
If the cover calls are sloppy and loose in a local match, you can bet those shooters MAY get called more than others. I've seen it happen with some of our guys.
The scope of differences can't be that large from range to range.
What's there to call on the FFR? The shooter is either moving forward in the stage or they are not. Shooter moves out before the slide closes? PE. How hard is that to call?
I just don't see where all the big problems are coming up. Most people don't like the FFR. It's the rule now. Deal with it until we get it changed!
AD (not affiliated, sponsored, "Liked" or even talked about all that much with anything having to do with IDPA HQ, World Peace or Whale saving)